The Correspondent

I’ve just read a novel, The Correspondent, by American author Virginia Evans. I finished it in three evenings – not because it’s ‘easy’ or ‘shallow’, but because it’s beautifully crafted and relatable.

It’s an epistolary novel, meaning it’s a work of fiction told through personal documents, in this case letters and emails, written by the characters themselves. The protagonist and letter-writer extraordinaire is Sybil Van Antwerp, a retired lawyer and chief clerk who lives in Annapolis, Maryland. Through the correspondence alone, Evans tantalisingly constructs a detailed picture of a past tragedy that haunts and defines Van Antwerp’s career, her relationships, and her letter-writing.

I’m not going to say any more about the novel because I don’t want to spoil it for anyone who might want to read it. The reason for my opening this blog with reference to this particular novel is because it inspired me to try writing a blog by copying and pasting from my own personal letters, emails, WhatsApp messages and the like. It's actually more difficult than you might think.

Water Councils
What rotten luck! I was stymied in the first instance by the following UK Parliament disclaimer at the bottom of an email from my Labour MP that I was going to reproduce:
this e-mail is confidential to the intended recipient ... Any unauthorised use, disclosure, or copying is not permitted…

This is all very frustrating. Am I now not allowed to reveal that my Labour yes-man-of-a-foot-soldier refused to help a constituent (me) because it was too much trouble, and instead directed me to a weblink, which turned out to be broken? Am I barred from describing how he failed to see the irony of his government giving power to the people – by way of water councils that interfere in the management of water companies – while removing power from the people in terms of the siting of data centres that over-need water, over-stress sewage treatment capacity and could exacerbate flooding? Indeed, water companies would have to prioritise serving the data centres ahead of any lofty aspirations of the water councils, making the whole exercise a complete and utter politically postured waste of time.

But the most delicious thing I can’t now show you is how I illustrated my argument that water councils, peopled by non-industry activists and politically motivated parochials, would likely base their decisions on self-interest and flawed science. Firstly, I pointed out to my MP that he had seriously misunderstood basic science and what makes a sewage overflow either inconsequential or tangibly polluting. I then slapped his wrists regarding his implicit claim that his personal involvement forced the local water company to act regarding the village sewage treatment plant, whereas I have irrefutable evidence (I visited the Plant years ago) that the water company had improvement plans on the table well before he was elected.

I hate those email disclaimers that shut me up. Wish I could think of a way round them.

Christmas Concert 
Another thread I thought would be fun to cut and paste was my post on the village Facebook page to promote my choir’s Christmas concert, and it drew a sinister response. Well, my post I can reproduce, but the comment it elicited is another matter. Illustrated with a stunning poster designed by our musical director, I wrote:
On November 28th, Stewkley Singers will perform Feel the Spirit, a choral cycle of seven African‑American spirituals arranged by Mr Christmas himself, Sir John Rutter. From the resounding “Joshua Fit the Battle of Jericho”, the lyrical “I Got a Robe”, and culminating with the toe-tapping, uplifting “When the Saints Go Marching In”, the evening promises to be nostalgic, poignant and celebratory.

To which, someone I’d never heard of commented with such vitriol that I wondered if it was April Fools’ Day. What did he say? Sorry, I'm not 100% sure, because his comment was so loathsome that some of my fellow choristers were taken aback at his unkindness, bordering on hate (not hope), which prompted me to report the comment to the group’s moderators, who removed it before I thought to copy it as evidence against the suspected actual perpetrator. It went something like (but was much worse than) this:
‘How dare you celebrate slavery and make light of the suffering of slaves and are you going to go black-face on the night’.

TBH, what’s more important than what was said is how I worked out who I think said it, and why his comment made me laugh out loud. I easily found that the perp joined the village Facebook page the day he posted the comment. Elementary, my dear Watsons, is the possibility that he saw the post when already a long-term member, under his real name, but was too cowardly (or embarrassed) to respond honestly. His false profile is blank, apart from two other Facebook groups he is following that are consistent with his assumed identity. The structure and style of the comment – in addition to the sentiments – also seemed familiar so, following a hunch, I checked members of another village Facebook page, and found the same false profile who was following the same two groups, and who joined that village page the day he posted a politically charged comment. He’s raised his ugly head there a couple of times since, to try and make it look as if causes dear to his ‘heart’ are more popular than they actually are. In fact, I realise now that he’s had a go at me once before – ooh, does that mean he’s a stalker? – but I missed the hiding-behind-a-false-identity-thing that time. Not anymore.

Why did his comment about slavery make me laugh when it caused my friends and colleagues a bit of angst? Because the Diocese is selling some local land for development, the sale proceeds from which could fund their ‘reparations for slavery that will make everything alright’.

Too much of a good thing?
Moving on from my Inspector Morse moment (some might say I’m more like Laurence Fox who, post Morse’s demise, played James Hathaway as the sidekick to Kevin Whately’s Endeavour), I trawled through my laptop, wondering if I could find a complete, uninterrupted and worthwhile thread I could share with you. Unfortunately, Choice A is too personal, Choice B is boring, and reproducing Choice C would see me up in front of the Information Commissioner. This is a real shame, because that latter protracted exchange is spicy, combative and showcases me at my fact-handling, logic-constructing best, while showing my adversary lagging behind in mental gymnastics (although he could still teach my 'stalker' a thing or two).

There’s nothing else of note in my emails or Facebook activity for this particular blog, and most of my WhatsApp exchanges would keep the Free Speech Union lawyers busy for evermore, so I won’t risk reproducing them in a public forum. Then there’s LinkedIn. I do try and tone it down (a larl bit) for this particular platform of ‘professional networkers’, but there’s still room for a bit of provocateur-ing sometimes. Here’s one example out of many:

The pile-on that fell off a cliff
Start of the original post from a left-leaning lawyer:
At the time of the last general election the FTSE 100 closed the trading session at 8,239.99 points. Today  (May 21, 2026), the index is trading around 10,387.84 points … I know that it’s not, in reality, necessarily a vote of confidence in the UK economy … but if the Conservatives had lucked into a run like this, nevertheless, I suspect it might have been considered worth a mention ...
[etc. He carried on in a pro-Labour, anti-Tory, anti-Brexit fashion that, for brevity, I’ve left out.] 

Me:
One could argue that our economy is doing comparatively well because of Brexit and the trade deals we have been / are able to negotiate. There's certainly no sign of the end-of-days as claimed by Project Fear.
[What I was doing here was not flying the flag for Brexit, but pointing out that it was inconsistent for the original post to claim that Brexit tanked the economy while lauding the current positive economic indicators. That’s all. Nothing else. But then …] 
 
Adversary 1:
… sorry I just need to check - was that sarcasm or an honestly held belief? My reason for asking is I had this conversation with my father a few months ago. As, following me making a first factual statement, it was clear he wouldn't listen to me I actually had the conversation with ChatGPT with me taking the position of pro-Brexit (using all and any arguments possible to leave no room for doubt, my father didn't add anything so I suspect I did a good job) 
The ChatGPT response (and as I knew would be the case due to the clear economic data) was that, in real terms, the UK economy is 10% smaller than it would likely have been had it remained in the EU - this is due mainly because of the massive impact to the financial services industry which forms a huge part of the UK economy 
If it was an honestly held belief, I am truly sure to break this news to you - having a firm closely held belief broken is never nice, and it's not nice to be the person who does so.

Me to 1:
ChatGPT? That's your source? Have a nice day.
 
Adversary 2 to me:
… Brexit was a massive con job, by truly nefarious influences. The EU annoys me a lot, but it's only those ideologically wedded, rather than using common sense or pragmatism, who still think Brexit was legit.
 
Adversary 3 to me:
A "trade deal" is not the same thing as "free trade". In some cases, trade deals are little more than a photo opportunity for politicians. The "trade deal" that the UK recently signed with the USA is a particularly interesting example because the USA bullied the UK into signing a deal that left it in a considerably worse position than it had been a year previously, with HIGHER tariffs than had previously been the case. Most of the post-Brexit "trade deals" have merely tinkered at the margins of the trading arrangements that had previously been in place.
 
Adversary 4 to me:
…  ah do you mean those deals that were effectively a copy and paste from the ones we already had when we were in the EU. Or the ones that completely favoured Japan/Australia/New Zealand and they couldnt believe their luck. Asking for a friend.

Ally:
… the original post shows hard data of a market increase of 20+%. Brexit driven ? Cant claim it both ways really only look at the hard facts as you mention ( and no I didn’t vote in the referendum).
[As I was saying]

Adversary 1 to Ally:
… the original post doesn't factor in inflation (as noted in my other comment to the original post, as opposed to my response to this thread and the ridiculous claim that the FTSE increase is causally linked to Brexit) and is only the FTSE not GDP/tax take/etc
Aside from the fact that almost all of the FTSE's increase is wiped out by inflation (the FTSE lags RPI by about 12 months, so inflation accounts for 15 percentage points) the facts (data from the referenced sources) clearly shows the UK's economy has been MASSIVELY hit by Brexit 
Don't get me wrong, as a Remainer I would now argue Brexit could be a good thing - but not for ANY of the arguments made for it in the referendum (or now), and at the same time note the disastrous economic impact of it 
The reality is for Brexit to be a good thing we need a change to how we select electoral candidates, no party can form a competent government it is statistically impossible because their sample sets are ridiculously small

Adversary 1 to Me:
… no, ChatGPT is not my source and I was clear about that in my comment - though clearly you, like my father, refuse to listen to anything that counters this closely held opinion.
Just for clarity, opinions are like a-holes - everyone one has one, and just because you hold yours sacrosanct doesn't make it special
The actual data is from the OBR, Bank of England, NBER, CEPR, UK Academic Research Network...
Why, where is your data from? And what does it say? Use some data to state facts, not opinions

Adversary 5 to Me:
… oh dear!
[Note that Adversary 5 claims to be a law student; but that’s all they could contribute? Let’s hope they have a fall-back career lined up.]
 
Me to Adversary 1:
   … Please introduce me to your father. He sounds like a nice bloke.

Is it any wonder that I have a stalker? 


Comments